Would you use FSPF or Fabled Battle fist in offhand?

[Catnip_Inny]

I just finished camping http://lucy.allakhazam.com/item.html?id=54813

but now i need to figure out what to use in my offhand beacuse the mace is 3.0 ratio naturally id assume putting that in main hand.

i have FSPF

http://everquest.allakhazam.com/db/item.html?item=83197

And Fabled battle firsts

http://everquest.allakhazam.com/db/item.html?item=74260

The pet claws have a lesser ratio but the pet procs would cover that im sure,  while the battle fists have higher ratio and would likely be better for discs?

would i see enough procs off my offhand to make the pet claws worth while?

I dont have a good parser set up anymore so cant really do in depth parses and id have to unfilter a whole whack of spam to see the actual parse.

Any input is always appreciated

Thanks
Cat

[Vidyne]

Only way to be sure would be to parse.  I think it would be close though, but I think FBF will win if offhanding.

Camping?  As in you didn't win that from a raid?

[Catnip_Inny]

No the new Vox/Naggy raids they put in unlock the items and if u dont win it through bids, you can acquire points via doing the group missions, this one cost 42 pts..

Id heard the save platinum fists with max pet AA parsed about the same as a 3.0 ratio weapon so thats why im still holding onto it up to now.

[Vidyne]

It will in a main hand when not discing and the pets are able to reliably hit their target, iirc.
However I'm not sure about offhanding it.

[Mazame]

WARNING. Soe has said that they WILL BE NERFING the MM's Gear. they are saying that the gear is greater then the new underfoot group gear and so by leaving them it make the new gear nul and void so they will be nerfing it all.

before you switch out I say but your old stuff in the bank and wait for the nerf before you make any perma changes.

[Catnip_Inny]

well all the higher stuff from the MM's is slot 8 so it should be higher than group gear... and yeah i expect a nerf but hoping its not too hash.... what they should have done was make the event harder so not every guild on the server could get a MM and go pwn the raid... im hearing of people 3boxing naggy.. thats just rediculous...

[Karve]

The nerfs are supposed to be on test, anyone checked them out yet ?

[Kanan]

since the main dmg from the fspfs is from the pet procs, you will be cutting the pet dmg in half by offhanding it (half the proc rate).

Given that, my instincts say Battle Fists.

[Karve]

And yes, offhanding FSPF really does seem to cut the proc immensly, so FBF for Offhard (depending on the outcome of the nerfing of the weapons from MM missions).

[Kanan]

/chuckle.. guess I'm glad I've not been playing much last few weeks to get those MM items and then see em nerfed ;p

[Karve]

I'm tentatively saving for one in the hope it won't be completely nerfed to pointlessnes. This thread however did open my eyes to just how poorly SFSPF performs when offhanded. Not sure its better than offhanding a dire cesti, but I'm back with FBF and Xangef's o/h'd  until  the next upgrade appears.

[Camikazi]

I'm tentatively saving for one in the hope it won't be completely nerfed to pointlessnes. This thread however did open my eyes to just how poorly SFSPF performs when offhanded. Not sure its better than offhanding a dire cesti, but I'm back with FBF and Xangef's o/h'd  until  the next upgrade appears.

FSPF is better offhand then Cestii, it's just as fast and only 3 dmg lower, the proc will outdo what those 3 dmg would. Melee dmg wise Cestii and Fists are very similar, think cestii does about 20-30 DPS more, but the proc in offhand would do around 150-180 DPS making it better. Add a 3 dmg aug into Fists and you get Cestii's melee dmg plus the proc.

[Karve]

I now have my new weapon.

Cold Iron Morning Star (Augmented)
MAGIC ITEM LORE ITEM NO TRADE
Slot: PRIMARY SECONDARY
Skill: 1H Blunt Atk Delay: 25
DMG: 79 AC: 49
Backstab DMG: +2
Effect: Might of Stone I (Casting Time: Instant)
Effect: Freezing Strike IV (Combat)
STR: 30 DEX: 24 STA: 47 CHA: 12 Wis: 27 INT: 18 AGI: 30 HP: 951 MANA: 919 Endurance: 919 SV FIRE: 48 SV DISEASE: 63 SV COLD: 48 SV MAGIC: 48 SV POISON: 33
Attack: +35
Mana Regeneration: +5
Damage Shield: 2
Damage Shield Mitigation: 1
Spell DMG: +7
Heal amount: +7
Clairvoyance: +13
Combat Effects: +3 Strikethrough: +5% Shielding: +3% Spell Shield: +5% Avoidance: +7 Accuracy: +9 Stun Resist: +1%
DoT Shielding: +3%
Recommended level of 75
Required level of 85
WT: 1.3 Size: MEDIUM
Class: WAR RNG MNK BRD ROG BST
Race: HUM BAR ELF DEF HEF DWF TRL OGR HFL GNM IKS VAH FRG DRK
slot 1, type 8: Crystal Embedded Discord Stone


Currently offhanding Xangef's, but have Fabled battle fists .. I guess I have the right one offhanded, does delay have any impact o/h or just damage?

[Khauruk]

does delay have any impact o/h or just damage?

[screams] Yes [/screams]

[Karve]

does delay have any impact o/h or just damage?

[screams] Yes [/screams]

yeah, was kinda thinking it might ..but you know how when you get old you start forgetting things and inventing others... well, thats me.